Another divisional breakdown as we get ready to head into the All-Star break. Today we visit the National League Central in which all six teams are within 10 games of the leader and five teams are within five games.
All rankings and records are current as of this writing.
1. St. Louis Cardinals (48-40)
Having the world’s best hitter definitely helps, but the Cardinals will head into the break leading the league’s most competitive division and it’s not all because of one guy.
The emergence of rookie Colby Rasmus and journeyman starting pitcher Joel Pineiro have helped thrust the Cards to the top of the NL Central. Chris Carpenter has maintained his dominance when healthy – and this season he has started 13 games. Throw in Adam Wainwright and Kyle Lohse and the Cardinals have four of their five starting pitchers with ERAs sub-4.00.
The offseason decision to move Skip Schumaker from the outfield to second base has paid off as it opened up a position in the outfield for Colby Rasmus. Schumaker and Rasmus have in turn been placed at the top of the Cardinals batting order which is quite important when you consider who is batting third. Schumaker is hitting .302 on the season while Rasmus’ average sits at .281.
Ryan Ludwick has faced a lot of criticism batting behind Pujols as he has struggled to offer him protection at the plate this year. However, in the last six games, Ludwick is batting .409 and has driven in 10 runs. That could be a sign that he is heating up.
SS Brendan Ryan has established some defensive stability in the infield and manager Tony LaRussa is widely considered to be one of the best in the game. If they can stay healthy, I think the Cardinals will end up winning this division as they are simply the most talented team.
2. Milwaukee Brewers (44-42)
It has been an interesting year for the Brewers. Their lineup is full of some excellent hitters as well as some really struggling ones but there are not many guys having average seasons.
We’ll start at the top with Prince Fielder and Ryan Braun. Both are hitting over .300, have 15+ home runs, 50+ RBIs and 50+ runs scored. They are definitely among the elite hitters of the National League. While not elite, 2B Casey McGehee has joined the over .300 club. An unknown going into the start of the year, McGehee has really turned it on when given an opportunity to play as Bill Hall is hitting below the Mendoza Line and Rickie Weeks is out for the season with an injury.
The Brewers do not have a single regular batting between .260 and .280. Corey Hart, Mike Cameron and J.J. Hardy are all hitting below .260 and have a high rate of strikeouts. Hardy struggled mightily last year as well but came back to have a decent second half so it’ll be interesting to see how he responds this year. I touched briefly on Bill Hall’s plate struggles and everyone knows about Jason Kendall’s lack of hitting ability. He’s hitting .233 and has just 10 extra-base hits in 249 at bats.
Milwaukee also has struggled on the mound. Last year they had C.C. Sabathia tossing routine complete games down the stretch as well as Ben Sheets for most of the second half. This season the Brew Crew has struggled replacing them. Yovani Gallardo has cut some of the slack by staying healthy and having a brilliant season. But Braden Looper, Jeff Suppan, Dave Bush and Manny Parra have all been worse than expected and have put the Brewers in a bind.
Trevor Hoffman has been average since his string of 18 consecutive scoreless innings came to a close a couple of months ago. Mark DiFelice, Todd Coffey and Mitch Stetter have definitely given Milwaukee some depth in a sound bullpen.
The Brewers will be able to make a move towards the playoffs if they can solve their starting pitching woes. I don’t really see that happening though unless they make a trade as I don’t have much faith that any of their four starters not named Gallardo will improve greatly from one half to the next. I see them finishing around .500 and in the middle of the pack in a tight NL Central.
3. Houston Astros (43-43)
It has taken a few career-years for the Astros to reach this point. The question is whether or not they’ll be able to keep it up.
Prior to the season if you were to have told me that Miguel Tejada would be batting .330, that Michael Bourn’s average would be at .289, Carlos Lee and Hunter Pence would both be above .300, Pudge would have 20+ extra-base hits and that Geoff Blum would be batting .281, I definitely wouldn’t have believed you. But all of these solid statistics are putting runs on the board for Houston and have them sitting at .500.
They’ve had pleasant surprises on the mound, too. Wandy Rodriguez’s ERA is a tidy 2.96. I didn’t think Mike Hampton or Russ Ortiz would even make a MLB team’s rotation at the beginning of the year but remarkably they have been solid and somewhat consistent on the hill. Roy Oswalt continues to eat innings and despite Rodriguez’s good start, Oswalt is clearly the ace of this staff.
An injury to closer Jose Valverde allowed LaTroy Hawkins to take over that role temporarily and so far both have succeeded. Valverde is healthy now, which leaves Hawkins in a setup role, but this bullpen has gotten the job done. Chris Sampson, Alberto Arias, Jeff Fulchino and Tim Byrdak all have been effective.
I sit and wonder how many guys can play so much better than expected for an entire season and just don’t see the Astros being able to keep this up. There definitely is some veteran leadership on this club with Berkman, Pudge and Darin Erstad out there. That could keep this team playing at a high level but I think a below-.500 second half is more likely as the Astros win 75-80 games.
4. Cincinnati Reds (42-43)
The Reds are my dark horse to win this division. Most people would say that the Reds have four really solid hitters in Jay Bruce, Brandon Phillips, Joey Votto and Edwin Encarnacion. Well only two of those four have really played to expectations and one of them has barely played at all.
Jay Bruce has 18 home runs. But other than that, his numbers are very poor. Batting just .208 this year, Bruce has only 41 RBIs hitting in the middle of the order for most of the season. He also has twice as many strikeouts as walks and manager Dusty Baker has decided to give him plenty of time off this week to clear his mind and get back on track for the second half. After seeing him perform at such a high level last year, it’s obvious that Bruce can play and is just hitting the sophomore slump. I think he’ll make the adjustments necessary to break out of it and help this team out for the remiander of the season.
Edwin Encarnacion has played just 27 games and is hitting .170 this year due to injuries. If he can get back to 100% I think he is capable of hitting .275 with 10 home runs in the second half.
The Reds have a decent rotation led by Aaron Harang and Johnny Cueto. Edinson Volquez’s injury has put a damper in the staff as they have struggled to find depth. Bronson Arroyo and Micah Owings have both been struggling with their control but haven’t been brutal. Cincy really needs that fifth starter, whether it be a healthy Volquez (who isn’t due back for at least another month) or Homer Bailey stepping up and pitching the way the Reds expected him to pitch when he was their top prospect just a couple of years ago.
Francisco Cordero has been one of the best closers in the game so far in 2009 and he’s been joined by a solid group featuring Nick Masset, Daniel Ray Herrera, Arthur Rhodes and Dave Weathers.
I say the Reds are my dark horse team to win the division because I can see many of their problems being fixed in the second half. They do lack depth, which could come back to hurt them if they suffer any more injuries. But if Encarnacion and Volquez can come back productive, Arroyo and Owings lower their walk totals, and Bruce makes some adjustments, this could be a very good team in September.
5. Chicago Cubs (41-42)
Boy must it be upsetting to be a Cubs fan. Nobody is running away with the division, yet the Cubs are all the way back in fifth place despite being just 4.5 games out. They’ve spent far more money than anybody else but seem to be in the news more for Lou Piniella and Milton Bradley’s antics than anything positive on the field.
There is hope, as I’m not sure Geovany Soto, Alfonso Soriano and Milton Bradley can play much worse than they have been. Aramis Ramirez is finally back which should help too. But doesn’t it feel like we’ve seen this several times before. A team with a high payroll and players under-producing, who just never seem to find a rhythm. You know its bad when Rich Harden has a higher batting average (.304) than anybody with 100+ at bats on the team.
Despite the struggles, Derrek Lee and Ryan Theriot have played very well and the Cubs have continued to receive solid outings from Ted Lilly and Carlos Zambrano. Statistically speaking, their best pitcher might be rookie Randy Wells who has dazzled with an arsenal of pitches and outstanding command. While Ryan Dempster wasn’t pitching like he did in 2008, he still was having a solid year until he broke his toe trying to celebrate a win. Rich Harden has been absolutely brutal. How much did the Cubs pay him for a 5-6 record and 5.47 ERA?
The pen has been a roller coaster as Kevin Gregg has gotten the majority of the save opportunities. Carlos Marmol has been largely disappointing walking a batter an inning. Aaron Heilman and Sean Marshall have seen the most innings in relief and both have been average but nothing special.
Will it finally click for the Cubs? Your guess is as good as mind. I can’t fathom them finishing the season below .500 and they probably have the most talent in the division so I would think that at some point they’ll get hot. However it could be too little, too late. And if that’s the case, there will be more griping among Cubs fans as “Wait Til Next Year” is recited once more.
6. Pittsburgh Pirates (38-48)
What started as a promising year for the Pirates – they went 11-11 in April – has slowly slipped away as Pittsburgh drops further and further away from .500.
I’ll start with the Pirates rotation which has been a bit better than most probably expected. Ross Ohlendorf, Paul Maholm, Zach Duke and Jeff Karstens have all had decent seasons and have stayed healthy. The addition of Charlie Morton from the Braves has rounded out the staff as Ian Snell was struggling. Still, despite the rotation being “decent”, they’re just not good enough to win many games on their own.
That brings us to their lineup which is not any better than average as well. Rookie Andrew McCutchen has easily been the most entertaining player to watch as his speed can change the game every time he steps to the plate. Every Pirate regular has a batting average above .255 and an on-base percentage over .300 but other than getting on base, there’s not much there. Pittsburgh has just one hitter with more than SIX home runs (Adam LaRoche has 12) and no that is not a typo. There’s not a single hitter in their lineup with 40 or more runs batted in. Those numbers just astound me. It’s tough to win games when Adam LaRoche is your best – and only – run producer.
I think the Pirates are headed in the right direction as McCutchen looks like he could be their best position player in a long, long time. Ryan Doumit finally came off the disabled list yesterday who also is one of Pittsburgh’s best hitters when healthy. They have a bunch of average arms which gives them more pitching depth than some other teams in their division. It’s just hard to see them competing for a playoff spot anytime soon without a commitment from upper management and a couple of run-producers added to the lineup.
Final Thoughts:
It’s easy to make the argument that this is a crappy division because nobody has really identified themselves as a great team. But the same logic could classify this as a solid division because nobody is really awful. The Pirates may not have a chance to make the playoffs but you know you’re going to face strike-throwers every time you play them. That makes it difficult to get hot when you’re playing five decent teams 18 times a year.
I believe this race will come down to the Cardinals and the Cubs which would make for a really fun September. Depending on how the Giants and Rockies play, this division may produce the Wild Card too. Injuries have been a big factor in how the NL Central has played out in the first half. I think whichever team stays healthiest will have an inside track to a playoff spot come October.